The jarred Indian sauces in most supermarkets are made by the same handful of big importers, heavy on cream, sugar, and stabilizers. The good ones come from cooks and chefs building their family recipes in small batches — you brown some meat or vegetables, pour in the jar, and simmer. Here's the founder-run end of the aisle.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
Cookbook author Chitra Agrawal and Ben Garvey started this in 2014 handmaking achaar at NYC markets, and deliberately kept it self-funded and investor-free to protect the recipes. The simmer-sauce line — Tikka Masala, Cashew Butter Masala, and more — is built on real spices and no artificial additives. A genuinely independent maker at national scale.
Why it isn't on AmazonA self-funded, investor-free brand keeps its recipes tight in a way a scaled-up, private-equity sauce line usually can't.
See it at Brooklyn Delhi →From James Beard Award–winning chef Meherwan Irani of Asheville's Chai Pani, whose "Masala Gossip" simmer sauces — Dal Tadka, Butter Masala — come out of an actual restaurant kitchen's playbook. Vegetarian and gluten-free, and made by the same small operation behind the well-regarded Spicewalla spices.
Why it isn't on AmazonSimmer sauces built from a working restaurant's recipes by a Beard-winning chef are a different animal from a generic importer's jar.
See it at Spicewalla →Founded by artist-turned-cook Nidhi Jalan, who moved to Brooklyn from Kolkata and built a tight line of four all-natural homestyle Indian simmer sauces. No artificial anything, made to taste like actual home cooking rather than restaurant-heavy cream. Small, personal, and free-shipped from her site.
Why it isn't on AmazonA four-sauce line from one cook's home recipes is the opposite of a mass importer's dozen-SKU catalog of the same base gravy.
See it at Masala Mama →Mumbai-born Rupen Rao makes his simmer sauces out of Washington, DC, built on his mother's homestyle curry recipe — masala, tikka masala, vindaloo, saag, and korma. Vegan and gluten-free, ready to pour over sautéed meat or vegetables. A one-person operation you can trace to a single kitchen.
Why it isn't on AmazonA single maker cooking his mother's recipe in DC is exactly the traceable, small-batch sauce the big importers can't replicate.
See it at Rupen Rao →Maya Kaimal left a Saveur photo-editing career to launch this in 2003, and she still runs product development with an Upstate New York team. Full transparency: the company took a private-equity investment from North Castle Partners to scale, so it's not a scrappy startup anymore — but the founder is still driving the recipes, and the Goan Coconut and Madras Curry sauces remain among the most respected in the category.
Why it isn't on AmazonIt's the most widely available real simmer sauce and still founder-led on recipes — the caveat is it took outside money, which is why we're straight with you about it.
See it at Maya Kaimal →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real curry & simmer sauces direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Brown your protein or vegetables in a pan first — chicken, paneer, chickpeas, cauliflower — then pour in the jar of sauce, add a splash of water to the empty jar and swirl it in, and simmer until everything's cooked through and the sauce thickens, usually 10–20 minutes. Serve over rice or with naan. That's the whole trick; the sauce does the heavy lifting.
Not really — a good simmer sauce is a shortcut past the labor-intensive part (building and blooming a spice base), and the makers here use real spices rather than shortcuts of their own. From-scratch will always be more customizable, but a founder-made sauce plus fresh meat and vegetables is a legitimately good weeknight dinner, not a compromise.
Tikka masala is mild, creamy, tomato-based; korma is rich and gentle with nuts and cream; vindaloo is tangy and hot, built on vinegar and chili; saag is spinach- or greens-based; Madras is a hotter South Indian curry. They start from different spice logic, not just heat levels, so it's worth trying a couple to find your lane.
Several are plant-based: Rupen Rao's sauces are vegan and gluten-free, and Spicewalla's Masala Gossip line is vegetarian and gluten-free. Brooklyn Delhi and Masala Mama make vegan options too, though cream-based styles like a butter masala or korma often aren't. Check the individual jar, but there are solid vegan picks here — just pour them over vegetables, chickpeas, or paneer's plant-based stand-in.
Make or grow real curry & simmer sauces and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.161