Frozen custard is ice cream's richer cousin — egg yolks and a slow, low-air churn make it dense and silky — and the best of it comes from decades-old family stands in the Midwest. Pudding, done right, is a stovetop dessert, not a plastic snack cup. These makers ship the real versions, packed in dry ice, from the counters that made them famous.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
A St. Louis institution serving frozen custard since 1929, so thick they famously hand you a 'concrete' upside down to prove it won't fall out. They ship pints and concretes anywhere in the continental US, overnight, packed with free dry ice. A nearly century-old family recipe you otherwise have to drive to Route 66 to taste.
Why it isn't on AmazonA 1929 family custard recipe served at one St. Louis stand is a place — the only way to taste it outside Missouri is to have them overnight it to you.
See it at Ted Drewes Frozen Custard →A Milwaukee custard landmark that ships boxes of ten pints, packed in dry ice by two-day air, often with their hot fudge and salted pecans to build sundaes at home. Wisconsin takes frozen custard seriously, and Kopp's is one of the names people drive across the state for. The Midwest custard tradition, mailed.
Why it isn't on AmazonWisconsin-style frozen custard from a decades-old Milwaukee stand isn't sold in stores — a shipped box of pints is how you get it anywhere else.
See it at Kopp's Frozen Custard →A Nolita shop that sells nothing but rice pudding, made from firm sushi rice in flavors like 'Sex, Drugs and Rocky Road' and 'Fluent in French Toast.' They ship it overnight from their own site. A single-dessert obsession that turns a nursery food into something worth crossing town — or the country — for.
Why it isn't on AmazonA shop devoted entirely to rice pudding makes a version no snack-cup brand touches — dense, real, and shipped fresh from the one counter that makes it.
See it at Rice to Riches →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real custard & pudding direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Frozen custard is made with egg yolks (by law, at least 1.4% by weight) and churned slowly with very little air, which makes it denser, silkier, and richer than ice cream. It's also traditionally served fresh and a bit warmer, so it's softer on the spoon. The egg and the low air are what set it apart — it's the reason a good custard feels heavier and smoother than even premium ice cream.
It's best served fresh from the machine and doesn't hold up as well as ice cream for long freezer storage, so it stayed a regional, made-on-site treat — especially in Wisconsin and Missouri. That's why the famous makers are decades-old local stands rather than national brands, and why ordering direct (in dry ice) is the main way to taste it elsewhere.
Yes. Shelf-stable pudding cups are built from starch, oil, and stabilizers to last months at room temperature. Real cooked pudding — like a proper rice pudding — is made from milk, sugar, eggs or rice, and cooked on a stove, so it's denser and tastes of dairy rather than of thickener. It's a different food that happens to share a name.
Frozen custard goes out packed in dry ice by overnight or two-day air, usually early in the week, and should arrive frozen — get it in the freezer right away. Rice pudding ships cold and overnight and should go straight into the fridge on arrival, then eaten within a few days like any fresh dairy dessert. Both makers avoid weekend transit so nothing sits in a warm truck.
Make or grow real custard & pudding and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.432