Supermarket frozen pizza is a cardboard disc built to survive shipping and a price war. Real pizzerias now flash-freeze the exact pies they serve in the dining room — same dough, same sauce, same cheese — and ship them to you on dry ice. Bake one in a hot oven and it's a genuine restaurant pizza, not a science-fair crust with orange grease.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
Lou and Jean Malnati opened their first pizzeria outside Chicago in 1971, and the family has shipped its buttercrust deep dish nationwide since 1987 through Tastes of Chicago, packed frozen in dry ice. Still family-owned, and it's the same deep dish they pull from their own ovens.
Why it isn't on AmazonA genuine Chicago deep dish — hours of build, a butter crust, layered cheese and sauce — is a restaurant pie flash-frozen and shipped cold, not a flat disc made for a freezer case.
See it at Lou Malnati's →Pequod's is famous for the ring of caramelized cheese it bakes onto the rim of its pan pizza, and it ships that pie frozen across the US and Canada. One of the most copied crusts in Chicago, sent straight from the pizzeria that made it a thing.
Why it isn't on AmazonThat caramelized-cheese crust is a specific pizzeria's signature — you can only get the real one from Pequod's, frozen and shipped, not from a national brand imitating it.
See it at Pequod's Pizza →A Salt Lake City institution that makes each pizza by hand from scratch, flash-freezes and seals it the same day you order, and ships it packed in dry ice by UPS Next Day. You're getting the pie fresh out of their kitchen, just paused in the freezer.
Why it isn't on AmazonA hand-made pizza flash-frozen the day it's ordered and shipped next-day is a made-fresh restaurant product — a supermarket pie was frozen months ago in a factory.
See it at The Pie Pizzeria →Chef Daniele Uditi's LA pizzeria ships its slow-fermented Neapolitan-style pies frozen and ready to bake at home, with the char and chew of a proper Naples crust. A different lane from the deep-dish makers — thin, blistered, and built around the dough.
Why it isn't on AmazonA slow-fermented Neapolitan crust is a craft product a chef obsesses over — the mass freezer aisle has no version of it, so it ships direct from the pizzeria.
See it at Pizzana →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real frozen pizza direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Get the oven fully hot first — most of these want a high temperature — and bake from frozen, no thawing. A preheated pizza stone or steel makes the biggest difference, giving you a crisp bottom instead of a limp one. Follow each maker's instructions, since a deep dish and a Neapolitan bake very differently.
No. A Chicago deep dish is thick and needs a longer bake at a moderate temperature so the center cooks through without burning the crust. A thin Neapolitan-style pie wants a very hot oven and only a few minutes. Using deep-dish timing on a thin crust (or the reverse) is how you end up with a burnt or raw pizza.
For the pizzerias here, yes — it's the identical pie they serve in-house, just flash-frozen, so you get their actual dough fermentation, sauce, and cheese. Grocery frozen pizza is formulated for cost and shelf stability, which caps how good the crust and toppings can be. You're paying more and getting a genuine restaurant pie.
These pies are flash-frozen and have to stay frozen through transit or the dough and cheese suffer, so makers pack them in insulated boxes with dry ice and usually ship early in the week. It should arrive frozen solid. Put it in your freezer right away, and bake within the window the maker suggests for the best crust.
Make or grow real frozen pizza and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.448