The guava paste aisle is a wall of one conglomerate's red boxes, sweetened to candy and cut with corn syrup. Real guava paste is just guava, sugar, and a little lemon, cooked down until it slices clean for cheese boards, pastelitos, and thumbprint cookies. This is a thin shelf — most 'independent' bocadillo is imported from Colombia — so here are the few US makers who actually cook fruit, plus one honest note on where the paste comes from.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
A California brand making guava paste, jam, and marmalade with no fillers or preservatives, from fruit grown in Calvillo, the Mexican town that calls itself the guava capital. The paste is dense and sliceable, the way it's meant to be for cheese and pastries. Certified kosher, non-GMO, vegan.
Why it isn't on AmazonThe paste is cooked from Calvillo guava rather than reconstituted from concentrate, so you're buying real fruit reduction instead of the corn-syrup block that dominates the aisle.
See it at Guava Gourmet →A Miami maker hand-cooking guava jam in small batches from three things: guava, pure cane sugar, and lemon juice. It's a jam, not a firm sliceable block, but it's a Good Food Award winner and the real spreadable version of the flavor. Also does a guava-habanero if you want heat.
Why it isn't on AmazonHand-cooked in small Miami batches from whole fruit and cane sugar — a jam maker's product, not a factory paste built to sit on a warm shelf for two years.
See it at Gables Delight →A South Florida operation working guava from Guavonia Grove in the Redland, turning handpicked fruit into purees, marmalades, and jams that South Florida restaurants and ice cream shops buy from them directly. Grower-to-jar, sold locally and by arrangement rather than through a big storefront.
Why it isn't on AmazonThey grow and pick the guava themselves in Homestead, so the fruit goes from grove to jar without the concentrate-and-reconstitute step the box brands rely on.
See it at PG Tropicals →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real guava paste direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Guava paste is the general term for guava cooked down with sugar into a firm, sliceable block. 'Bocadillo' is the Colombian name for it (often sold as small individually-wrapped bars). 'Membrillo' technically means quince paste, a Spanish cousin made the same way — the words get used loosely, but if a jar says membrillo it's usually quince, not guava.
Guava is a tropical fruit grown at scale in Colombia, Mexico, and the Caribbean, and the paste has been a commodity export for a century — so the aisle is dominated by a few big importers. Genuinely US-made guava products are rare and mostly come out of South Florida, where the fruit actually grows. That's why this is a short, honest shelf rather than a deep one.
Slice it thin over a firm salty cheese (manchego or a sharp cheddar) for the classic pairing, melt a cube into pastelitos or thumbprint cookies, or whisk it into a glaze for pork or chicken. It keeps for months and a little goes a long way, so one block lasts.
Buy the firm paste (Guava Gourmet) when you want to slice it for cheese boards or bake it into pastries where it needs to hold shape. Buy the jam (Gables Delight) when you want to spread it on toast or swirl it into yogurt. They're the same fruit, different textures for different jobs.
Make or grow real guava paste and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.183