Here's the honest truth: the gummy aisle is owned by a handful of giants, so genuinely independent gummy-making is a thin field. The chew side is healthier — real saltwater taffy is still pulled by hand at family shops, and a few makers do gummies with real fruit and no artificial dye. Here are the independents worth ordering.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
Founder Mayssa Chehata built these with chef Elizabeth Falkner: gummy bears sweetened with monk fruit and prebiotic fiber instead of a pile of sugar, no artificial colors or flavors, and just a few grams of sugar per bag. A rare founder-run, women-led operation in a category dominated by multinationals.
Why it isn't on AmazonAn independent, chef-developed gummy with real ingredients is exactly the product the giant gummy brands don't make — you order it direct because the grocery aisle is their turf, not hers.
See it at BEHAVE →A family taffy maker using an egg-white whip that gives their saltwater taffy a lighter, almost nougat-like chew, in dozens of flavors you can mix by the bag. Each batch is made, cut, and wrapped by hand and shipped nationwide. The everyday taffy pick when you want a big assortment.
Why it isn't on AmazonHand-pulled, whipped taffy in this many flavors is a specialty run — the assortment and the fresh chew are why you order it by the bag instead of grabbing a stale box.
See it at Taffy Town →Saltwater taffy still made by hand from an original 1919 recipe and shipped nationwide — the soft, slow-pulled kind that actually tastes like the flavor on the label. A single-focus taffy maker keeping a state-fair tradition going. Straightforward and well-made.
Why it isn't on AmazonA hundred-year-old hand-pull recipe is a craft, not a manufacturing line — fresh taffy ships soft and pliable in a way a shelf-worn box never is.
See it at Sutter's Taffy →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real gummies & chews direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Very few. The gummy category is dominated by large multinationals and their brands, so most 'artisan' gummies are actually made by the same big co-packers. The genuine independents tend to compete on a real difference — lower sugar, real fruit, no artificial dye — like BEHAVE does, rather than trying to out-scale the giants.
It's a soft, chewy candy of sugar, corn syrup, butter, and flavor that's aerated by pulling — stretching and folding it repeatedly so it turns light and holds a chew. There's no seawater in it; the name is old seaside-boardwalk marketing. Fresh taffy is soft and pliable, while old taffy turns hard and sticky.
Traditional gummies get their bounce from gelatin, which is animal-derived, so they aren't vegetarian or vegan. Pectin (from fruit) is the usual plant-based substitute and gives a slightly different, shorter texture. Check the label if that matters to you — makers who use pectin or kosher gelatin will say so.
Both are shelf-stable and travel well, so no cold pack needed. Heat is the only real enemy: in hot weather taffy can go soft and gummies can clump together, though they usually recover once they cool down. Store them sealed at room temperature and out of the sun.
Make or grow real gummies & chews and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.327