A bagged supermarket marshmallow is corn syrup, gelatin, and artificial vanilla — engineered to survive a year on a shelf. A real one is whipped in small batches from cane sugar and actual vanilla bean, soft enough that it barely holds its shape. Once you've toasted a handmade one over a fire, the bagged kind is hard to go back to.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
Kat and Lindzi started XO in 2016 and opened the first-ever marshmallow café in Chicago the next year. Handcrafted gourmet marshmallows — cookies-and-cream, vanilla, seasonal drops, plus spreadable marshmallow — all egg-free, gluten-free, no high-fructose corn syrup, no preservatives. Ships across the US and beyond.
Why it isn't on AmazonA dedicated marshmallow company with its own café obsesses over texture and flavor in a way a shelf-stable national brand never will — and real ones have to ship fresh, not sit in a warehouse.
See it at XO Marshmallow →Husband-and-wife team Nathan and Jenn Clark have been handcrafting marshmallows since 2012 out of downtown Sanford, near Orlando. Over 75 flavors including a Marshmallows Across America collection of 50 for the 50 states, plus boozy varieties and hand-dipped chocolate. Made without high-fructose corn syrup or preservatives, shipped nationwide.
Why it isn't on AmazonThe sheer range — 75-plus rotating flavors from one small kitchen — is something only a hands-on maker can pull off. A mass producer runs three SKUs forever.
See it at Wondermade →An independent, small-batch marshmallow maker rooted in Austin (with a Toronto arm), started by a founder who turned a marketing side project into a gourmet marshmallow company and opened a café in Texas. Handmade gift boxes and share boxes built for gifting, shipped across the US.
Why it isn't on AmazonThese are made in small batches to order and boxed as gifts, not stamped out on a line — the reason they arrive soft instead of shelf-hardened.
See it at The Fancy Marshmallow Co. →Founded by Alexx, a classically trained pastry chef, and made in tiny 17-bag batches in a celiac-safe Vermont kitchen. Boldly flavored and not-too-sweet — toasty vanilla, cinnamon sugar, dulce de leche, seasonal drops. Ships nationwide, free express over $75.
Why it isn't on AmazonSeventeen bags at a time from a dedicated gluten-free kitchen is the definition of small-batch; a pastry chef's not-too-sweet recipe is a specific point of view you won't find in a bag at the store.
See it at The Vermont Marshmallow Co. →A woman-owned company in Southern New Jersey built on a vanilla recipe the founder developed over roughly 20 years of holiday baking. Signature 'The Artisan' pairs vanilla marshmallow with house-made caramel and dark chocolate; flavors run to cherry-pistachio and pecan-toffee, plus barrel-aged confections and a monthly subscription box.
Why it isn't on AmazonBarrel-aged and confection-layered marshmallows are a maker experimenting far past what any packaged brand attempts — a 20-year home recipe turned into a small business.
See it at The Artisan Marshmallow Company →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real marshmallows direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Yes. Supermarket marshmallows are built around high-fructose corn syrup and stabilizers so they last a year and hold a perfect cylinder. Handmade ones use cane sugar and real vanilla, so they're softer, less rubbery, and actually taste like something. Toasted over a fire the difference is dramatic — they go golden and molten instead of just charring.
Most traditional marshmallows, including these makers', use gelatin, so they're not vegetarian or vegan. Several are egg-free and gluten-free (XO and The Vermont Marshmallow Co. call this out specifically), which matters for those allergies. If you need vegan, look for marshmallows made with agar or carrageenan instead, and always check the individual maker's ingredients.
Generally two to four weeks at room temperature in a sealed container, versus the near-eternal shelf life of the bagged kind — that's the trade-off for no preservatives. Keep them airtight and out of humidity so they don't get sticky or dry out. You can freeze most of them for a couple of months if you want to stretch it.
They melt beautifully into hot chocolate (several makers sell spreadable or drinking-cocoa versions), top sweet potatoes, and make a real Rice-Krispie-style treat that's worlds better than the boxed version. Flavored ones — cinnamon sugar, dulce de leche, cookies-and-cream — are good enough to eat straight out of the box. Toasting deepens the flavor of any of them.
Make or grow real marshmallows and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.198