The molasses most people know is Grandma's or Brer Rabbit — both owned by B&G Foods now. Real cane and sorghum syrup is a different thing: cane juice or sorghum cane cooked down in open kettles by mills that still grow or press their own crop. These are the ones worth keeping in the pantry for gingerbread, baked beans, and BBQ.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
C.S. Steen's has cooked 100% pure cane syrup in Abbeville, Louisiana since 1910, in open kettles with no preservatives — the golden-yellow-can cane syrup that anchors Cajun and Creole baking. They also make a pure dark molasses. If you've only ever cooked with grocery molasses, this is the one that changes your gingerbread.
Why it isn't on AmazonOpen-kettle pure cane syrup is a regional Louisiana product a handful of mills still make; the mass-market bottle is a different, sulphured processing entirely.
See it at Steen's Syrup Mill →Golden Barrel is the retail brand of Zook Molasses Company (Good Food, Inc.), a family operation in Lancaster County, PA since 1934. They sell the full range — sweet Supreme Baking molasses for shoofly pie and cookies, and unsulphured blackstrap for baked beans and where you want the mineral-heavy, bitter edge. Non-GMO cane, no additives.
Why it isn't on AmazonA four-generation Pennsylvania Dutch molasses house ships the specific grades bakers actually want (baking vs. blackstrap), not one generic bottle built for the widest shelf.
See it at Golden Barrel →A Mennonite family mill in the Tennessee hills between Nashville and Knoxville, pressing 100% pure sorghum syrup from cane they plant themselves each year. No additives, non-GMO, gluten-free. Sorghum is milder and greener than blackstrap — the Southern biscuit-and-butter syrup, and a real one.
Why it isn't on AmazonSorghum is a seasonal, labor-heavy crop pressed by the few families who still grow it; a mill that plants its own cane is about as direct as sweetener gets.
See it at Muddy Pond Sorghum →Another Muddy Pond family, the Mazelins press sweet sorghum molasses during the fall harvest and take mail orders year-round. A traditional, small-run sorghum for cornbread, biscuits, and glazes. Between them and Muddy Pond Sorghum, this one Tennessee hollow makes some of the best sorghum in the country.
Why it isn't on AmazonHarvest-run sorghum from a single family sells out and ships by mail — it's made once a year, not manufactured on demand.
See it at Mazelin Family Sorghum →An Amish-style kitchen in Hamptonville, North Carolina cooking pure sorghum cane molasses the old way — slow-boiled to a thick, dark, earthy syrup — alongside their jams and BBQ sauce. Small-batch and homemade, sold direct and through Amish-food grocers.
Why it isn't on AmazonA tiny Amish kitchen cooking molasses in small batches is the opposite of a national syrup line — you're buying one family's kettle work.
See it at The Dutch Kettle →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real molasses & cane syrup direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Regular (or 'baking') molasses is cane juice boiled once or twice — sweet, for gingerbread and cookies. Blackstrap is boiled a third time until most sugar is gone, leaving a dark, bitter, mineral-rich syrup used in baked beans and as a supplement. Sorghum syrup isn't molasses at all — it's pressed from sorghum cane, milder and greener, and it's the classic Southern biscuit syrup.
It's the one sweetener with real mineral content — meaningful iron, calcium, potassium, and magnesium survive the boiling that strips out the sugar. It's still sugar, so it's not a health food, but a spoonful carries more nutrition than any refined sweetener. The trade-off is a strong, slightly bitter flavor not everyone loves straight.
Roughly, but they're not identical. Steen's cane syrup is lighter and sweeter than molasses; sorghum is milder with its own tang. In most recipes you can swap them and get a good, slightly different result — sorghum especially shines on biscuits and in glazes. For deep gingerbread or baked beans, blackstrap or dark molasses gives the flavor you're after.
Open-kettle syrup is boiled down in shallow pans without the sulphur dioxide, evaporators, or vacuum processing of industrial molasses, so it keeps a rounder, more complex flavor. It's slower and yields less, which is why only small mills still do it. It's the difference between a syrup that tastes like cooked cane and one that tastes flat and one-note.
Make or grow real molasses & cane syrup and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.190