Most 'feta' in the US tub is a rubbery, over-salted commodity cheese sitting in brine, and a lot of it is cow's-milk shortcut feta. A proper feta — sheep or goat milk, brine-aged, crumbly but creamy — is a specialty. Genuinely independent American feta makers are few, so this is a short, honest shelf of the ones doing it right.
Published July 2026 · Updated 7 Jul 2026
A multi-generation Providence family creamery — Mark and Pattie Federico have made cheese for nearly 25 years — whose Salty Sea Feta, made from whole milk and sea salt, took a gold medal at the Wisconsin World Cheese Championships. Firm, briny, and clean. They ship their fresh cheeses to your door.
Why it isn't on AmazonA gold-medal, whole-milk brine feta from one family creamery is a made-to-order product — the tub feta at the store is a different, commodity thing.
See it at Narragansett Creamery →A family creamery in the Finger Lakes making cheese since 1982, whose feta is a firm, salty, Balkan-style cheese made entirely from goat milk and aged a month in salt brine. An American Cheese Society award winner. Their shipping runs seasonally — roughly resuming in the cooler months — so it's a plan-ahead, regional-leaning buy.
Why it isn't on AmazonAn all-goat-milk feta brine-aged on a small Finger Lakes farm is a specialty cheese with a seasonal shipping window — nothing like a year-round commodity tub.
See it at Lively Run Dairy →This seat's open on purpose — we won't pad the list to hit a number. If you ship real feta direct, it's earned, not sold.
Add your brand →Traditional feta — and the protected European kind — is made from sheep's milk, or a sheep-and-goat blend. Goat-milk feta, like Lively Run's, is firmer and tangy; sheep-milk feta is richer. A lot of American tub 'feta' is cow's milk, which is legal to call feta here but tastes blander and rubberier. Check which milk you're getting.
Feta got commoditized — big plants make cow's-milk versions cheaply, and the sheep and goat dairies that make traditional feta are small and few. Brine-aging takes time and space, and shipping a wet, briny cheese is finicky. So the honest answer is the field of real independent US feta makers is small; we'd rather show you two good ones than invent a longer list.
Yes — keep feta submerged in its brine (or a light saltwater solution you can mix at home) in the fridge, and it stays moist and lasts much longer, often a few weeks to a couple months. Feta left dry in the fridge dries out and sharpens fast. If it gets too salty for you, soak a portion in fresh water for a few minutes before eating.
Block feta stored in brine is almost always better — pre-crumbled feta dries out, is often coated with anti-caking agents, and loses its creamy edge. Buy the block, keep it in brine, and crumble it yourself as you go. It's a real difference in both texture and flavor.
Make or grow real feta and think you belong here? Tell us → — features are on merit, never for sale.
Some "see it at…" links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who makes the list. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy · Worth The Hunt · No.319