Sweet Potato Pie — Ad-Free Recipe, Ingredients First

Roasting the sweet potatoes instead of boiling drives off water and concentrates the flavor, which is the difference between a rich pie and a watery one. Bake the custard only until the center barely jiggles; it sets as it cools.

The Ingredients — and where to get them

Cook for 9 servings

Sweet potatoes

Roasting concentrates the sugar and dries the flesh so the custard sets clean.

2 lb

Local / market

Eggs

They set the custard; do not overbake or they curdle and weep.

Source it →

Milk

Evaporated milk or cream gives the custard body and richness.

1 cup

Source it →

Unrefined sugar

Sweetens and deepens the color; brown sugar works well here.

3/4 cup

Source it →

Spices

Cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla carry the warmth this pie is built on.

2 tsp

Source it →

Butter

Melted into the filling for richness and used in the crust.

3/4 cup

Source it →

Baking flour

Low-protein flour for a tender single crust.

1 1/4 cups

Source it →

The Rundown

Greedometer ●●●●● A fair little treat

A reasonable little indulgence. · plan ahead — needs marinating, soaking, or resting time

EffortSome doing

Cook it with

Sheet pan

The Method

Roast the potatoesRoast whole at 400F for 50-60 minutes until collapsing soft, then scoop and mash smooth.
Par-bake the shellLine the crust with parchment and weights, blind-bake at 375F for 15 minutes, then remove weights.
Mix the fillingWhisk mashed potato with eggs, milk, sugar, melted butter, and spices until smooth.
Fill and bakePour into the par-baked shell and bake at 350F for 45-55 minutes.
Check donenessPull it when the edge is set but the center still jiggles slightly; it firms as it cools.
CoolCool completely, at least 2 hours, before slicing.

The Toolkit

Pie dish 9-inch · Potato masher · Pie weights · Whisk · Rolling pin · Cooling rack

Straight Answers

Can you make Sweet Potato Pie in an air fryer? — Sometimes

You can, but a custard needs gentle, even heat and usually a water bath the basket can’t give, so the top tends to set before the middle. Bake it in ramekins that fit and watch closely, or use the oven for a foolproof set.

Can you freeze Sweet Potato Pie? — Not ideal

Not really — the cream, custard, or emulsion turns grainy or splits once thawed. This one is best kept fresh in the fridge.

Can you make Sweet Potato Pie ahead of time? — Yes

Yes — bake it a day or two ahead; it keeps well-wrapped at room temperature and freezes cleanly. Add any frosting or glaze close to serving.

Is Sweet Potato Pie gluten-free? — Not as written

Not as written — it contains gluten. Make it gluten-free: swap in a gluten-free flour blend (check the other labels too).

Is Sweet Potato Pie vegan? — Vegetarian, not vegan

It’s vegetarian but not vegan as written — it has dairy and egg. Make it vegan: use plant milk, oil, or a vegan cheese for the dairy, and a flax or aquafaba egg for the egg.

Community Notes

Cooked it? Changed something that worked? Leave a note for the next person — first-name basis, no account.

Loading notes…

More American recipes

Buttermilk Pie Strawberry Pie Peach Pie Apple Turnovers Blackberry Cobbler Dutch Apple Pie

All American recipes → · Browse all 1433 →

Some ingredient and tool links are affiliate links — if you buy through one, 5best2buy may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never costs the maker anything, and it never decides who we recommend. The list is the list.
© 2026 5best2buy.com · Recipe No.544

Sweet Potato Pie, and where to source it