5best2buy.com › States › Wisconsin

Independent Food Makers in Wisconsin

41 independent makers based in Wisconsin that ship direct to you, across 11 aisles. Each one earned its place on a shelf before it appeared here.

The Greengrocer

1913 Kickapoo Orchard

Gays Mills, WI · Century-Old Wisconsin Orchard

Apples Worth the Hunt

Keene Garlic (Keene Organics)

Madison, WI · Wisconsin Grower Co-op

Garlic Worth the Hunt

North Bay Trading Co.

Brule, WI · Air-Dried Since the '80s

Dried & Freeze-Dried Vegetables Worth the Hunt Onions & Shallots Worth the Hunt Winter Squash Worth the Hunt

North Bay Trading Co. (Air-Dried Carrots & Beets)

Brule, WI · Air-Dried, Not Freeze-Dried

Root Vegetables Worth the Hunt

The Daily Catch

Baileys Harbor Fish Company

Baileys Harbor, WI · Door County, WI

Trout & Freshwater Fish Worth the Hunt

The Drink Cart

Bittercube

Milwaukee, WI · Nine Varieties, Milwaukee

Cocktail Bitters Worth the Hunt

Calypso

Milwaukee, WI · Glass-Bottle, Real Lemon Bits

Lemonade & Limeade Worth the Hunt

Rishi Tea & Botanicals

Milwaukee, WI · Milwaukee Tea House

Chai & Concentrate Worth the Hunt Green Tea (Sencha, Gyokuro) Worth the Hunt Rooibos & Honeybush Worth the Hunt

Top Note Tonic

Milwaukee, WI · Real Quinine Tonic

Cocktail Mixers & Syrups Worth the Hunt Tonic & Craft Mixers Worth the Hunt

The Pantry

Century Sun Oil

Pulaski, WI · Barn-Pressed Organic

Cooking Oil Worth the Hunt

Great River Organic Milling

Fountain City, WI · Mississippi River Family Mill

Oats & Hot Cereal Worth the Hunt

Maple Valley Cooperative

Cashton, WI · The Organic Co-op

5 Real Maple Syrup Producers Worth the Hunt

Milwaukee Pretzel Co.

Milwaukee, WI · The Bavarian One

5 Artisan Pretzel Makers Worth the Hunt

Nordic Creamery

Westby, WI · The Grass-Fed Sweet Cream

Craft Butter Makers Worth the Hunt 5 Cultured Butters Worth the Hunt

Potter's Crackers

Fitchburg, WI · The Cheese-Board Native

5 Artisan Cracker Makers Worth the Hunt

Quince & Apple

Madison, WI · Wisconsin Small-Batch

Pie Filling & Fruit Preserves for Baking Worth the Hunt

Sartori

Plymouth, WI · The Award-Winning Wisconsin

Parmesan Worth the Hunt

The Spice House

Milwaukee, WI · 1957 Spice Merchant

Ginger Worth the Hunt

Underground Meats

Madison, WI · The Worker-Owned One

5 Small-Batch Charcuterie Makers Worth the Hunt Nduja & Spreadable Salami Worth the Hunt Saucisson & Dry Salami Worth the Hunt

Wetherby Cranberry Company

Warrens, WI · The Century Bog

Fresh Cranberries Worth the Hunt

The Cold Case

Cheese Brothers

Almena, WI · Almena, WI · Ships Anywhere

Cheese Spreads & Fondue Worth the Hunt

Crave Brothers Farmstead Cheese

Waterloo, WI · Four-Brother Dairy

Mascarpone & Creme Fraiche Worth the Hunt

Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery

Ellsworth, WI · Farmer Co-op, 180+ Farms

Cheese Curds Worth the Hunt

Henning Cheese

Kiel, WI · Family-Run Since 1914

Cheese Curds Worth the Hunt

Kraemer Wisconsin Cheese

Watertown, WI · Spreads & Fondue Cheeses

Cheese Spreads & Fondue Worth the Hunt

LaClare Family Creamery

Malone, WI · Family Farmstead, Since 1978

Goat Cheese Worth the Hunt

Marieke Gouda

Thorp, WI · Dutch Farmstead, Raw Milk

Gouda & Aged Dutch-Style Worth the Hunt

Nasonville Dairy

Marshfield, WI · Central Wisconsin Family Dairy

Cheese Curds Worth the Hunt

RPs Pasta

Madison, WI · Wisconsin Pastificio

Fresh Pasta Worth the Hunt

Uplands Cheese Company

Dodgeville, WI · Most-Awarded US Cheese

Swiss & Alpine Cheese Worth the Hunt

Vern's Cheese

Chilton, WI · Fourth-Generation Cheesemakers

Cheese Spreads & Fondue Worth the Hunt

Snacks & the Jerky Drawer

GoMacro

Viola, WI · Mother-Daughter, Family Farm

Energy & Snack Bars Worth the Hunt

Jackson's

Muskego, WI · Avocado-Oil, Allergen-Free Facility

Veggie & Root Chips Worth the Hunt

The Mill

Great River Milling

Fountain City, WI · Organic Stone Mill

Amaranth & Sorghum Grain Worth the Hunt

Sweets & Bakery

Kopp's Frozen Custard

Milwaukee, WI · Milwaukee Custard Institution

Custard & Pudding Worth the Hunt

New Glarus Bakery

New Glarus, WI · Swiss-Village Bakery

Croissants & Pastry Worth the Hunt

The Butcher

Northstar Bison

Cameron, WI · Family Herd, Field-Harvested

Bison & Buffalo Worth the Hunt

Strauss Free Raised

Franklin, WI · Pasture-Raised, Never Crated

Veal Worth the Hunt

Usinger's

Milwaukee, WI · Brick-Smokehouse, 1880

Deli & Ham Worth the Hunt

Heat & Sauce

Silver Spring Foods

Eau Claire, WI · Family Grower Since 1929

Cocktail & Seafood Sauce Worth the Hunt Prepared Horseradish Worth the Hunt

The German & Nordic Pantry

Westby Cooperative Creamery

Westby, WI · Wisconsin Dairy Co-op

Brunost & Brown Cheese Worth the Hunt